Importance of Keeping Good Tax Records
Let me tell you about Lisa and Jimmy.
They had a very unsatisfactory visit with the IRS. The auditor examined their three rental properties, disallowed their losses, and told them to expect a tax bill for $55,000.
Current score: IRS $55,000 ahead.
Here’s why you must keep good tax records. Doing so changed everything for them!
The IRS acknowledged that Lisa qualified as a real estate professional. Luckily, this helped. But, her logbook included over 750 hours of involvement, though a large portion counted as investor hours and not material participation. According to the IRS, she came up short of qualifying hours under their standard interpretation.
This is the part most taxpayers misunderstand: Material participation does not rely only on the 500-hour rule. That rule is just one of seven IRS material participation tests. Without proper documentation, people end up losing deductions they are entitled to claim.
Rental Portfolio
- Condo rented month-to-month
- Single-family home rented month-to-month
- Vacation cabin rented weekly for 20 weeks annually
- No personal use at all
Preserving proof of rental activity, tax records, time logs mattered more than they realized.
How We Helped Them Overturn the IRS Assessment?
We started by clarifying the regulation – IRS Reg. Section 1.469-5T(a)(1) offers several ways to prove material participation and not just hours. We implemented the right strategy plus good documentation to make a difference.
-
The Condo – Qualified Under the ‘More Than 100 Hours’ Test
We utilized the 100-hour material participation rule. This requires the taxpayer to spend more than 1pp hours and more time than anyone else.
Referencing the Pohoski case, we argued that comparison hours apply specifically to their unit and not general desk staffing time. The IRS accepted this position.
-
The Single-Family Home – ‘Substantially All’ Test Applied
Lisa and Jimmy handled everything related to this property themselves. This met the substantially all participation test – another IRS-approved method to establish material participation.
-
The Vacation Cabin – Hours Exceeded Outside Help
A housekeeper worked about 70 hours for the season, which is ≈3.5 hours × 20 weeks.
Lisa and Jimmy’s combined time exceeded 100 hours. It surpassed the housekeeper’s time. Also, it satisfied material participation again.
The Result of Good Tax Record-Keeping
Finally, they kept good tax records, activity logs, receipts, and property documentation. We were able to fully defend their deductions. The IRS issued a NO-CHANGE letter. This eliminated the entire $55,000 tax bill.
Accurate tax records are beyond paperwork that:
- Protect your deductions
- Support your rental activities
- Help you win audits
If you own rental properties and wish to guarantee the strength of your tax position, call either me or Rick at 281-288-0909. Our tax consulting services will guide you through proper tax recordkeeping and IRS compliance. We assure you that your money stays where it belongs – with you.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Why is keeping good tax records important?
Good tax records:
- Prove material participation
- Support deductions
- Protect during audits
- Help maximize rental tax benefits
What tax records should rental property owners keep?
- Time logs
- Receipts
- Leases
- Mileage records
- Invoices
- Communication logs
- Repair costs
- Depreciation schedules
- Proof of activity
How do you prove material participation to the IRS?
Prove material participation to the IRS through documented hours of involvement. Meet any one of the IRS’s seven material participation tests to qualify – not just the 500-hour rule.
Can poor recordkeeping cause the IRS to deny rental losses?
Yes. Without evidence, the IRS can disallow deductions. Your strongest defense is accurate documentation.
Who can help if I want my rental tax records reviewed or prepared properly?
You can call us anytime at 281-288-0909 for guidance with rental property tax support, IRS audit help, and tax planning services.
Also, read:
